HOME  
Pool e-mail updates:
WHO IS TO BLAME?
KEY CONTACTS
WHAT YOU CAN DO

December 2005:
"Community Labor" team launched for council election.
Justin Madden, Telmo Langueller and Brendan O'Connor hand out How-To-Vote cards for standing Labor councillors wearing ALP shirts and brandishing huge colour "Community Labor" posters.

Madden hands out cards for Natalie Suleyman who is now mayor again.

Natalie cheered and applauded when previous Mayor Sam David threatened gallery with cancelling the whole pool redevelopment process.

14 years and the 'Labor Team' has refused to repair or adeqately replace our 50 metre pool.

It is time for the community to rally and raise funds so we can fix the pool ourselves - like we did in the late 50's when we first built the bloody thing.

October 2005: Its 13 years now and our three outdoor pools are still not repaired. Reports by consultants have indicated the remaining 25 metre - 6 lane indoor pool is the most used pool in Victoria. It is so over crowded that less than 30% of the population bother going there anymore. And now $7.6 million dollars of community and State Government funds later, and Brimbank Council have applied for a permit to build a three foot deep indoor pool - and to bury the Olympic Pool and two other outdoor pools forever...
Brimbank City Council commits to meaningless community consultation.

October 2005: Brimbank Council rejects plan to build an outdoor pool. Recreation manager Carol Julian claims council will review the situation in 2 or 3 years time. i.e. It will be 16 years before they even consider building or fixing our outdoor pools. Two generations of teenagers won't swim...ever!

October 2005: Dept Victorian Communities survey indicates Brimbank is the least active of Victoria's 79 local government areas and has very poor recreation and leisure facilities and infrastructures. Will Justin Madden allow the councillors to spend State Government funds on a useless three foot deep pool with no masterplan, no thought for 2030 and let them bury hundreds of square metres of existing aquatic space?

August 2005: Council confirms intentions to build a 3 foot deep wading pool as replacement to the 50 metre pool. Council ignores fact that Sunshine has the least aquatic space in Victoria. Labour Unity Councillor Ian Douglas states he has had talks with union officials in council. Union officials say there was no contact and that bans remain in place.

April 2005: Sunshine Swim and Leisure centre redevelopment still not included in the Brimbank Aquatic Strategy...
Consultants refuse to include Sunshine Pool in Brimbank Acquatic Strategy.
Read more..

 

 

 

 

We invite all State MPs, councilors and residents to correct any information by posting to the open forum!


The Brimbank Council and State Labour Government
Sunshine Pool Shame File

 

Fact File:

  • Brimbank has the worst access to aquatic facilities / water space of any major city in Victoria.

  • Brimbank residents have one of the lowest (if not the lowest) per capita rates of access to aquatic services in Victoria.

  • A recent Department for Victorian Communities survey indicates Brimbank is the least active of Victoria's 79 local government areas and has very poor recreation and leisure facilities and infrastructures.

  • Brimbank Council will be spending $9.5 million (plus GST) to build a pitiful 3 foot deep indoor pool... and have tried to start work to demolish and bury the three outdoor pools (including the 50 metre, 10 foot deep end Olympic pool) The State Government's Better Pool Funding grant will only contribute $1.4 million to the project, residents in this poor socio-economic area will have to pay the rest!

  • Brimbank City has a population of over 170,000 people and is steadily growing. It has the largest population of all municipalities in the Western Region.  The youth population is higher than the Melbourne average. Despite this there are few recreational facilities for the local youth. Most teenagers in Brimbank have never had a deep water or outdoor pool experience...

  • Justin Madden, Telmo Langueller and Brendan OConnor handed out How-To-Vote cards for standing 'Community Labor' endorsed councilors at the 2005 council elections helping them back into office by a slim margin. It becomes clear that the Labor councillors (who dominate all council decisions) and the local Ministers are a 'team' and it is this team that are the reason that our outdoor pools are not being repaired.
  • Labor endorsed Councilor Ian Douglas was elected by a narrow 80 votes on the ticket "We Have Saved the Pool". Councilor Douglas preference was actually to turn the 50 metre outdoor pool into a car park! (Read more)

  • Despite Brimbank and the Melbourne West being so under serviced with aquatic and other community facilities, when our beautiful outdoor 50 metre pool cracked due to council/swim centre mismanagement, council elected to close the pool....long term.

  • Brimbank Council keeps 'pretending' that they are 'saving the pool'. 15 years have passed!

  • Despite the astounding lack of aquatic facilities and recreational opportunities in Sunshine councilors were considering permanently closing the Sunshine Pool. Residents would travel to other suburbs to swim outdoors. A recent report has shown that the proposed pool in Maribyrnong will not be big enough to service the people in Maribyrnong in 2005 let alone the people in Sunshine, St Albans, Deer Park and Footscray. (Footscray pool is scheduled to be closed - Highpoint has about the equivalent water space but Bruce Mildenhall and Justin Madden refer to it as a 'regional pool' and refer to it when Sunshine is raised...)

  • After much public pressure Ian Douglas and Bruce Mildenhall became part of a reference group in August 2003 to decide what would happen to our outdoor pool in the near future. Ian Douglas has said repeatedly that his plans are to turn the outdoor pool into a car park. Bruce Mildenhall appeared somewhat disinterested at the community meeting and appears focussed on the aquatic centre in Highpoint. The community feared that the 'reference group' was just a sham and that these two in particular have no interest in repairing the outdoor pools. Bruce however did state in parliament that Sunshine required three swimming pools. He has since gone quiet on the Sunshine pool and will only refer complainants to Highpoint.
  • After a year of propaganda from council about how the reference group's new pool plans meet community needs. Council refuses to consult with the community, councilors still refuse to answer any question relating to the outdoor pool at council meetings. When one member of the public asked if the new proposed plans could be seen he was told 'they are not public documents'. This is called community consultation in Brimbank.
  • After waiting another 12 months for the council to being the consultation process for the re-development of the Sunshine Swim and Leisure centre the Brimbank Council advertised and invited residents to participate in the 'Brimbank Aquatic Strategy!' The consultants at the two public sessions for the aquatic strategy announced at the beginning of each meeting that Sunshine was 'not' allowed to be discussed!
  • The Brimbank area is a traditional Labor voting stronghold. This is how we are rewarded.

  • Steve Bracks has awarded Brimbank Council "2003 Premier’s Award for Continuous Improvement in Local Government. Brimbank won Category A (Whole of Council) for its Best Value process!!" This award is confusing because the perception of the community is that because we live in a Labour strong hold this is how we are rewarded. Discussions with people on the street about council will also bring forward comments like "They are hopeless", "Don't expect them to do anything for the community". Ten years later and our pool is still in disrepair.

    Some of the more historical sabotage from the council to try and hide their lack of progress with the pool include:

    • Fixing the outdoor pool is not a repair job but a new development! Council says new developments are subject to the recently revised council car parking rules for new developments! (Even though the pool is surrounded by huge car parks!) Surveys have also shown that many people like walking to the pool. It is also only 2 minutes walk from the train station and bus terminus. Fitzroy outdoor pool was repaired and they have very minimal car parks.

    • "There is a drought so we don't have enough water to fill an outdoor pool." (This was declared by a council representative at a council meeting) Why can Prahran pool and Fitzroy pool etc be filled?

    • Bruce Mildenhall tells us on August 14 2003 that development of 'new' outdoor pools is 'rare'. (We don't necessarily need a 'new' pool. The minimum we want is our 50 metre pool 'fixed', just like the Fitzroy pool is getting fixed.) Meanwhile Clayton 50 metre outdor pool is fixed, Fitzroy outdoor 50m pool is replaced, Glen Waverley gets a 20 million dollar pool upgrade, Harold Holt outdoor 50 metre pool has a new boiler installed and is open 12 months of the year.
    • After intense community lobbying council finally applied for a Better Pool Funding application. The State Government awarded 1.4 million dollars toward the repair of our pools! The total funds available increased to 6 million dollars! Wow, we thought we were getting somewhere!!!?
    • No.........surprise, surprise, council decides to spend the $6 million by covering the outdoor polls with concrete and bitumen for car parking and a road despite the pool site being surrounded by car parks and vacant land! The new proposed pool was on average 2 foot deep at best, 3 feet deep at the deep end! This, Ian Douglas pontificated, would meet the needs of 95% of the community!
    • The councils consultants recommend that 10 million dollars be spent if the pool was to be redeveloped in a way that would meet the needs of the 65000 people in the area however the Brimbank councilors reject that additional funds are required (Mayor Sam David council meeting Oct 12th 2004)
    • Community members offer to assist in sourcing additional funds through large business, grants and fund raising activities but the Mayor declined the offer.
    • The criminal thing is that the council keep 'pretending' that they are 'saving the pool'. A day before the recent save the pool rally the council put up posters outside the pool saying they are committed to 'fixing the pool', but at every council meeting, and every time we have asked, they have never said anything about repairing the outdoor pool. Its another lie; they deflect, sabotage, promise but have shown no real commitment...yet.


      Contact them and ask!

Some other good stuff about Brimbank

  • Brimbank community is recognised as being significantly disadvantaged and having the most vulnerable communities in Australia.
  • Brimbank is significantly disadvantaged in relation to health status (Best Value Review.. 2002)
  • Males in Brimbank have a significantly below average life expectancy (Best Value Review....2002)
  • Brimbank community demand for aquatic services has continued to grow over the past decade as Brimbank’s population has grown but aquatic facilities have been closed rather than expanded over that period
  • Sunshine's 3 outdoor pools were closed progressively from 1994 with no community consultation and no formal announcement, apparently as the result of council's failure to properly maintain and repair them

    Us

    Our 50 metre outdoor pool cracked and the Brimbank Council wants to bury it.
    Them   Fitzroy's 50 metre pool cracked and it was repaired for approx $1.7 million dollar.


    A local's viewpoint:

    We have an olympic sized outdoor swimming pool in Sunshine.

    It is laid out very much like Prahran pool. It is ten foot deep at one end and 3 foot at the other end.

    Every hot day during summer, from primary school years right through to high school years, me and 6 or 7 mates in the neighbourhood used to walk 2 or 3 kilometres in our shorts, walking in thongs and with towels around our necks, and we'd spend the whole day swimming, diving, racing in the pool, and later sun baking and relaxing on the lawns by the pool.

    Hundreds of other kids and families would be there, young mothers and little kids in the toddlers pool, primary school kids chasing each other and laughing in the huge square two foot deep pool, old Greek mothers, Yugoslavs, Aussies, lovers, young and old, wading or cooling off and laughing in the huge pool.

    In the 100 times I went there, never once did I see a fight there, an argument, despite all of the different types. The pool was great; the water was cool, who needed to argue when you could instead do a huge bomb off the diving board into the ten foot.

    I also went there for swimming lessons and did my primary and safety tests as did countless of other teenagers in the area. We went there for school sports during primary school, and we had inter-school competitions there in high school. Sunshine Tech vs Sunnie West High vs St Johns etc.

    A memorable moment was when Terry Coombs, (who we all knew was training toward serious swimming achievements), beat the pack by more than half a pool length in the breast stroke. For some reason they decided breast stroke would go across the width of the pool. Coombsy (as the chant went up) was three quarters across the width before he emerged from his initial dive and touched the other end after two hurtling strokes while all the other competitors floundered three metres from the start position, trying to work out something resembling a drowning butterfly. The Sunshine Tech mob cheered and cheered while we all looked on in amazement.

    Years later, perhaps 1984, in my early twenties, I went to the pool weekly in the morning and did laps to try and gain some fitness. I did ten laps of the big pool each time. One day I tried a few more. I found a rhythm and did 33 laps. It was the most I had ever swum and I felt triumphant.

    One day they said the pool had cracked. They drained it, said it was closed and that they were not going to fix it. It was a very sad day. That was ten years ago...

    The alternative was the humid, chlorine choked tiny indoor pool. Eeek. A few times I drove all of the way to Prahran so I could swim in a proper pool but it was just too far away.

    Since then the kids in the Sunshine area have very few places they can go. There is no skate park, no pool, nothing. The council spends all their time selling real estate and collecting rates. No money goes toward the pool.

    One wonders what would happen if the Prahran pool 'cracked'. Would they shut it down? Yeah right!

    Our problem is that because we have a majority labour electorate the councilors and local MPs are under no pressure to please the community.

    For those of us who grew up at the Sunshine Pool it is a tragedy. We know how many people used to love this pool, how the youth would have pride in their physical natures, bodies on show, laughter and water fun.

    Now the kids either stay at home playing their Playstations, watching TV, or walk around in the street despondent, smashing bus shelters, no outlet, no sense of community, no meeting place, no fun.

    A few months ago my brother-in-law called. "Hey, Simon. Check your mail box; they are going to save the Sunshine Pool!"

    I couldn't believe it. He was right, there was a pamphlet in our mail box a few days before council elections titled: "WE HAVE SAVED THE SUNSHINE POOL"

    It was from Councilor Ian Douglas.

    I was beside myself with joy. Finally some sense.

    I looked at the plans on the back of the pamphlet.

    Here is the rub: On close examination of the new plans it showed the outdoor pool (same size as Prahran pool) and it was to be filled in and turned into a car park!

    It then appeared to me as if Councilor Ian Douglas had blatantly conned the electorate a few days before the election. My brother-in-law (an Electronics wizard) saw the pamphlet and thought the pool was saved. It was extremely misleading. The pamphlet should have read : "SUNSHINE POOL TO BE CONVERTED INTO A CAR PARK"

    How he tried to milk this as saving the pool baffles me to this day. The plans would basically increase the size of the gym by a small percentage, make some repairs to the undersized, and stuffy indoor heated pool and destroy the Sunshine 50 metre Pool forever.

    Douglas was voted in by the tiniest of majorities; his leaflet had worked!

    Another false hope came up. After selling off the huge Massey Ferguson land, council told us that a new outdoor pool would be built beside the new Sunshine Marketplace.

    Brimbank Council then proceeded to sell that piece of land for $3.2 million and have indicated that these funds will 'not' go toward redeveloping our outdoor swimming pool. (Update Sep2003: Council after mounting pressure say now they will put the money toward the pool but only on condition that the State Government also adds another 1.4 million. If they State Gov doesn't pitch in the council will not act. The councils last submission to the State Gov. was a one page stick figure diagram (true) Why can't they just put out a tender and fix the outdoor pool now? (will cost approx 1.3 million which they say they have) and then do further prolonged 're-developments' later. (This is what they are doing with the Fitzroy Pool)

    The outdoor pool is absolutely essential to our community; particularly the young kids who would find a physical outlet, for young kids who would learn to swim, for the community as a whole, to those of all ages that would like to lie down on their towels in the sun or under the trees on the lawns (all still there) and to go for the big splash into the pool to cool off.

    There is something absolutely corrupt about the pool being closed for this long and I can only assume that it is the current councilors that are now fully to blame.


    A whole generation of teenagers have missed out on learning to swim, to mastering a 50 metre pool, of sun, socialising and exercise in the sunny Australian outdoors.

    There is still some hope however: people power. If we can come together as one large voice as a community, the citizens of Sunshine, they will have to listen. This has worked for the Fitzroy pool which was actually closed. When the people protested as a group, the Fitzroy council listened, and their whole pool (which also 'cracked') is now under reconstruction!


Visit the Sunshine Community Pool Action Group website

Any images and text on this site can be used freely by any organisation or media outlet without permission!

www.savesunshinepool.com


www.savesunshinepool.com is a non politically aligned website.
The only party we support is the pool party we all have once they fill the repaired outdoor pool with water.